Behind the Screens: Conflict Minerals and Toxic Waste
by Marisa Buxbaum


mining congo


Consumers in developed nations live in a world dominated by gadgets. In our pockets, iPods and Blackberries have taken up permanent residence; in our homes, laptops and televisions are considered practically essential. Some of us may marvel at the innovative feats that have turned our cell phones into mini-computers, especially given the convenience they provide. Being unable to see or understand their inner workings can give modern electronics a magical quality, but a disturbing story hides beneath the sleek exterior of modern tech.

The production of the electronics we use requires the mining of raw materials. Four of these materials are high-value minerals: gold and the “3Ts” – tungsten, tin, and tantalum (refined coltan). Gold coats the internal wiring in the guts of your computerized devices, and tungsten is used to enable the vibrate function in cell phones. Tantalum is necessary in allowing battery-powered electronics to hold a charge when unplugged from electrical outlets. Lastly, tin is a sodder essential to the manufacture of circuit boards.  All of these resources can be found in the Democratic Republic of Congo, where militant groups smuggle and tax the appropriately-named “conflict minerals,” drawing in $183 million yearly to fund their violent operations. Since 1996, more than 5.4 million people have died as a result of ethnic warfare and struggles for the Congo’s wealth of resources. Militias such as the FDLR, which profit from the illegal sale of gold and the 3Ts, terrorize miners into laboring for them – raping local women and girls, and killing those who refuse to work. If workers are paid, the average is $1 to $5 a day, and conditions are dangerous and inhumane. Child labor is frequently employed.



Above video, from the Enough Project. For a step-by-step explanation of the “Mines-to-Mobile Phone” process and details of the supply chain: www.enoughproject.org


Eliminating the use of conflict minerals in electronics production poses challenges, but none are insurmountable. From their war-torn origins, the mined minerals are shipped off to smelting refineries in Asia, where their mixture with other materials complicates efforts to trace them.  It would add a penny to the cost of a cell phone, however, if an auditing process were used to verify claims of ethical production from suppliers (see NYT's “Death by Gadget”). And while no electronics companies are currently manufacturing conflict-free, increased awareness has effected some proactive legislation. The passage of a 2010 law requires that publicly-traded companies submit annual reports to the Securities and Exchange Commission on the acquisition of component metals, and what is being done to determine whether metals sourced from Congo are indeed conflict-free (LAT's “Congo’s Conflict Minerals").

Currently, companies that use conflict minerals are not penalized under the law. But buyers of consumer electronics have the power to demand conflict-free products from manufacturing giants. Visit RaisingHopeforCongo.org to commit to buying conflict-free and sign their web form here: www.raisehopeforcongo.org. Of the 21 largest electronics manufacturers in the world, you can buy your cell phones, computers, cameras, and other gadgets from those companies that are making the most effort to go conflict-free (and avoid those that are not).


Companies with the best track record thus far:

Dell
Hewlett Packard
Intel
Microsoft
Motorola
Nokia

Companies with room for improvement:

Acer
Apple
IBM
Lenovo
LG
Philips
Research in Motion (Makers of the Blackberry)
Samsung
Sony Ericsson

Companies that have done little or nothing to go conflict-free:

Canon
Nintendo
Panasonic
SanDisk
Sharp
Toshiba

(raisehopeforcongo.org)


Congolese mining not only fuels bloodshed, but results in the displacement and killing of endangered gorilla populations. Militant groups pay no heed to the protected status of national parks, and the extraction of gold and the T3s destroys natural habitat (see “Guns, Money, and Cell Phones": www.globalissues.org). The environmental impacts of our tech-thirsty consumer culture do not end with Congo, as the manufacturing of electronics is damaging regardless of mining locale. The electronics industry thrives on disposable products – gadgets that are easily tossed away in favor of their newer, faster, and fancier replacements. The resource demands that feed this cycle are immense, and consequently, so is the resulting pollution. Take, for instance, the production of a single desktop computer, which requires 240 kg of fossil fuels – roughly ten times the weight of the computer itself. To put this in perspective, the fossil fuels necessary for most other consumer goods is roughly equal to the weight of the good itself (Source). Resource extraction for electronics manufacturing occurs globally, generating huge amounts of waste and leaving environmental degradation in its wake. Below is a graphic showing some areas where this extraction is most significant, and what materials are sought after:



conflict minerals map
Source


These materials must be processed in factories before they can become the component parts of our electronics, exposing workers to toxic solvents, flame retardants, and mercury. While this labor is now largely outsourced, it once occurred in our own backyards. According to a Johns Hopkins study in 1992, female IBM employees in Silicon Valley suffered high rates of miscarriage that were correlated with solvent exposure in computer chip manufacturing – 2.8 times greater than those who were unexposed (see storyofstuff.org and www.deseretnews.com). These days, the poisonous chemicals are handled mostly by workers in developing countries. The average computer workstation contains over 700 compounds, of which many are harmful: lead, cadmium, barium, bromine, and carbon black, to name a few (Source). Upon reaching the end of their lifespan, most spent electronics return to those nations in which they were processed, such as India and China, completing the toxic exposure cycle during disassembly. The U.S. alone generates 3 million tons of electronic waste yearly, and the EPA estimates that trashed tech is growing at two to three times the rate of any other waste source (Source 1&2).  Of the measly 13% that is collected for recycling, roughly 50-80% is shipped overseas. In Mustafabad, India, citizens attempt to scratch out a living by burning this “E-Waste” into its constituent minerals, allowing vaporized solvents, flame retardants, and even acid to be breathed in. Sadly, children will often participate in this dangerous activity.






Some manufacturers are making progress, implementing “takeback” programs in an effort to recycle E-Waste more responsibly. The Electronics TakeBack Coalition has compiled a recycling “report card” for major electronics companies and retailers here, so consumers can make informed decisions about which ones to support: www.electronicstakeback.com. To ensure that your electronic devices are properly recycled – and not dumped in developing countries – look for an E-Stewards recycler here: e-stewards.org.



Workshop for Companies:

BSR Conference 2011- A broad range of companies are begining to face conflict mineral reporting requirements. The question remains how best to go about integrating this issue into supply chain sustainability programs and gather needed information, no matter where a company sits in the supply chain. This session will use specific industry case studies in a workshop format to lay out some of the challenges that companies face and how they might develop solutions. November2 - San Fran. www.bsr.org



Resources:

1) Overview of Conflict Minerals, from The Enough Project’s Raise Hope for Congo: www.raisehopeforcongo.org
2) How a certification process can eliminate the use of conflict minerals: “Certification: the Path to Conflict-Free Minerals in Congo.” Sasha Lezhnev and David Sullivan, 2011. The Enough Project: enoughproject.org
3) GoodGuide’s guide to buying an ethically-produced cell phone, based on social, environmental, and health analyses: www.goodguide.com
4) Wall Street Journal article from this April on the conflict mineral disclosure legislation: wsj.com
5) Recycle it Right: the Electronic TakeBack Coalition’s guide to recycling your electronics: www.electronicstakeback.com

*** Conflict-Free Smelter (CFS) Program: Compliant Smelter List. A new fund backed by Intel, HP and the GE Foundation aims to lower the cost for smelters that seek to prove they're conflict-free: www.conflictfreesmelter.org
**** Public-Private Alliance for Responsible Minerals Trade. U.S. State Dept: www.state.gov



 

Share this page...
Become a Fan of Inspiration Green

 

 

 

Write a comment

  • Required fields are marked with *.

If you have trouble reading the code, click on the code itself to generate a new random code.
 
timothy tope
Posts: 2
Comment
school project
Reply #2 on : Tue May 27, 2014, 17:15:25
What happens to the conflict minerals when we throw them away or dispose of are old cell phones and stuff I was looking for the answer but I cant find it on anything
ALEXIS
Posts: 2
Comment
idk
Reply #1 on : Wed May 08, 2013, 18:47:44
hi
Green Tech Blog Additional Posts
Showing 1 - 20 of 35 Articles
< Previous 12 Next >
Hydrogen Fuel Cell Cars
 
Lease a hydrogen car! Hyundai has just released the first mass produced hydrogen fuel cell car in the U.S.. Meet the 2015 Hyundai Tucson Fuel Cell. One thousand are to go into production next year.
Spherical Solar
 
Squeezing more juice out of the sun. Meet the Rawlemon Solar Energy Generator.
The Solar Conundrum
 
New designs that decrease heat and therefore produce more energy.
New Wedge Cars
 
A three wheeler and an electric...
Biomanufactured Brick
 
We could keep 800,000,000 tons of CO2 out of the atmosphere, if we grew our bricks rather than fired them.
Mineral Carbonation
 
The raw material serpentine (right) and product carbonate (left). In the back: ETH Zurich's newly built mineralization plant. Turning CO2 into stone...
Methane Hydrate
 
The Japanese have announced they have successfully extracted methane from a methane hydrate reservoir 30 miles off Japan's east coast and 980 feet beneath the seafloor. They are the first to have achieved this feat.
Algae Streetlight
 
A self-powered microalgae street lamp that absorbs one ton of CO2 a year.
Solar-Driven Fuel Production
 
Solar radiation, a common metal oxide, water and carbon dioxide combine to produce transportable hydrogen fuels.
Urine Powered Generator
 
Urine is already widely used as a nitrogen rich fertilizer. Now some young girls in Africa give us hope our urine can also power our appliances.
Plastic Waste Fuel
 
Converting plastic into oil. The technology is here and it is not excessively polluting. Could it save our oceans?
PowerTrekk
 
Got water? And a Power Trekk? Then you have instant power to charge any electronic equipment charged via a USB.
Greenpeace Guide to Greener Electronics
 
The Guide ranks 15 leading mobile phone, TV and PC manufacturers on policies and practices to reduce their impact on the climate, produce greener products, and make their operations more sustainable.
Kitchen of the Future
 
We need to go back to nature in order to move forward. The Microbial Home is a proposal for an integrated cyclical ecosystem where each function’s output is another’s input. In this project the home has been viewed as a biological machine to filter, process and recycle what we conventionally think of as waste – sewage, effluent, garbage, waste water.
Greenpower Education Trust
 
Greenpower Education Trust is an educational initiative established to offer schools an exciting way to introduce their students to green engineering. The young students design, build and race their own eco-race cars. By getting pupils hooked on engineering while they’re still young the project aims to inspire the next generation to develop solutions.
Windstalk
 
When the wind sways the poles, the stack of piezoelectric disks is forced into compression, thus generating a current through the electrodes.
7th Grader mimics Nature
 
Thirteen year old Aidan Dwyer was waking in the woods in Upstate New York in the winter and noticed a spiral pattern to tree branches.
Conflict Minerals
 
The uncomfortable issue of the minerals in your cell phone and laptop...
What if Solar got Subsidies
 
Two Solar Infographics. What if Solar got Fossil Fuel Subsidies,,,and Why the Military is in love with Solar Energy?
Appliances of the Future
 
The Electrolux Design Lab winners and more. The Electrolux Design Lab theme for 2011 was Intelligent Mobility...
 
Showing 1 - 20 of 35 Articles
< Previous 12 Next >