Home Page Home Page Home Page

A Reorganization of the Seas
by Marisa Baxbaum

    Evidence is mounting that our seafood preferences are causing a vast shift in the composition of aquatic ecosystems. Unless the developed world can curb its appetite for big fish – species such as tuna, cod, swordfish, marlin, grouper, haddock, sharks, and skate – these creatures will soon exist only in biology textbooks and Hemingway novels.

ocean predator fish
Threatened by overfishing. Illustration by Richard Ellis

     Globally, fish comprises 12% of our per capita calorie intake. In 2006, 76 million tons of commercial seafood – or seven trillion individual fish – were caught and consumed. Industrial fishing practices have become so effective that numbers of predator fish, like the ones pictured above, are dwindling. Using historical data on catch rates from 1880 to 2007, scientists at the University of British Columbia found that populations of predatory fish across the globe have declined by two thirds in the past 100 years – with 54% of that decline occurring over the past four decades. This 2011 study follows another published in 2003, which concluded that industrial fishing has eliminated 90% of large ocean fish.^ As a consequence, as fishing efficiency has gone up, catch rates have gone down; only one successful catch is made per 100 longline hooks, as opposed to 10 per 100 at the onset of industrialized fishing technologies. Those fish that are lucky enough to avoid the longlines and gillnets are not numerous enough to reproduce sustainably. While UBC researchers do not foresee a totally fishless ocean by 2050, they do predict a massive ecological reorganization: without predator controls on the population growth of prey fish, oceans will be inhabited mostly by smaller species. Already, numbers of these prey fish have more than doubled over the past century, following the decline of their natural enemies. Although in some locales, such as the North Atlantic, herring and other small fish are in jeapordy due to unmonitored midwater trawling.^ And in the Pacific, populations of sardine, anchovy and herring are being taken in ever increasing numbers to feed cats, dogs, chicken and the growing numbers of farmed fish.*

ecosystem overfishing

     This is cause for concern, as big predator species are vital to ecosystem balance.^ Without predatory fish, we can likely look forward to murkier, less diverse waters. As populations of certain small, foraging fish increase, so does the incidence of algal blooms. This is because the small foragers eat zooplankton, which in turn consume algae. The loss of predator fish may thus precipitate a deep green sea, robbed of oxygen by these suffocating algal blooms and rendered uninhabitable to most aquatic organisms.

     Climate change, in conjunction with overfishing, will also pose a threat to ecosystem vitality. Heavier rainfall, predicted to occur mostly in tropical areas, may form a surface layer of warmer, fresher water that does not mix well with the denser, colder, and saltier layers below it. This stratification of the water column inhibits the circulation of deep water nutrients, which plankton – the base of the marine food chain – need to survive. Fewer plankton means less food for fish, affecting species growth all the way up the food web. Another problematic factor is ocean acidification, caused by higher levels of dissolved CO2 in the water. Coupled with warming, acidification may put excess stress on fish and further limit their growth. Those species that simply cannot handle the changes can be expected to move to more habitable waters. This includes over 50% of our current stocks, which may relocate by up to 40 kilometers per decade.

     Sharks – of which 100 million are harvested yearly – are needed to maintain healthy seagrass beds and coral reefs through similar food web mechanisms that keep foragers in check.^ But since shark fins are a delicacy than can fetch up to $500 per pound, the economics of the trade are outweighing the need for conservation efforts. Only three species out of 350 – the white, whale, and basking sharks – are actually protected from the international fishing trade, and the fishing process itself is both cruel and wasteful: once the fins are removed, the shark is usually tossed overboard to slowly die. Sadly, sharks are now as endangered as they are unfairly demonized: they constitute the largest group of threatened marine animals on the World Conservation Union’s Red List.

shark fins

     Even though their flesh accumulates higher levels of toxic mercury and other contaminants, it’s the big, predator fish that are preferred on our dinner plates. Industrialized fishing practices have enabled our oceanic scouring, but these practices cannot be blamed any more than increasing dietary demand. Fifty percent of that demand increase can be attributed to East Asian countries, and 42% of that to China. Western nations are also guilty. In Britain, native waters are so overfished that restaurants and household kitchens must rely on imports six months out of the year.^ The depleted state of 70% of U.S. fisheries prompted Congress to tighten federal catch limits in 2006, but fish stocks are still in jeopardy as of 2011:

fish populations US
U.S. Dept of Commerce, National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, National Marine Fisheries Service Office of Sustainable Fisheries.

     Unless demand lessens and stricter regulations are imposed on the fishing industry, predator fish – and the ecosystems they help support – will have little chance for recovery. The continued existence of wild oceans depends on our willingness to change our palates. For links to more sustainable seafood choices, see:

Additional Sources:

A list of commercial fishing methods, including their environmental impacts, at the Monterey Bay Aquarium website:
SeafoodWatch seafood reports on the statuses of both farmed and fish species, also from the Monterey Bay Aquarium website:

Forage Fish are declining as well:
*Forage Fish Should Stay in the Ocean:






Write a comment

  • Required fields are marked with *.

If you have trouble reading the code, click on the code itself to generate a new random code.
Posts: 3
Carson City Restaurants
Reply #3 on : Sat October 25, 2014, 06:03:44
You should take part in a contest for one of the finest sites online. I am going to highly recommend this web site!
Posts: 3
Re: A Reorganization of the Seas
Reply #2 on : Sat March 09, 2013, 09:28:29
SHARK tail fishing is one of the most cruel thing Ive ever seen :(
humans can be so cruel it's just dusgusting!
Posts: 3
this website
Reply #1 on : Tue August 02, 2011, 12:01:08
Thank you for this effort!
  • Sumatra, Kalimantan and Papua
    Haze crisis. Indonesia is now the second largest emitter of CO2 in the world, just behind China.
  • Sister Earth
  • The Largest Picture Ever Taken
    Our Universe is absolutely huge! We are but a speck in space.
  • Climate Accountability of CO2
    The Climate Accountability Institute has updated its Carbon Majors Project which details the direct and product-related emissions traced to the major industrial carbon producers in the oil, natural gas, coal, and cement industries through 2013.
  • Avgas
    Avgas (aviation gas) contains lead and avgas is unregulated. Aviation aircraft is the single largest source of lead emissions.
  • Record Warmth in July
    Record Warmth in Northeastern Canada, Norway, Denmark. Record cold in Indiana and Arkansas.
  • Global Water Volume
    Our oceans are but a thin film on Earth's surface.
  • Not in My Backyard!
    Exxon CEO files suit to stop construction of a water tower to be built adjacent to his Texas ranch.
  • Perfluorotributylamine
    Chemicals should be tested for their global warming effect (radiative efficiency) before being placed into production.
  • Flammable Ice
    Methane hydrate, will it be a godsend and replace dirty coal and oil within the next five years, or will it delay our investment in renewable energy and set us on an ever longer road of hydrocarbon addiction?
  • Tar Sands
    A destruction of the world's resources, leaving long term greenhouse gas emissions, water pollution and habitat loss.
  • Nursery Pollutants
    A new infographic from Healthy Child, Healthy World.
  • EDCs a "global threat"
    The World Health Organization and the United Nations Environment Programme have just listed endocrine disrupting chemicals (EDCs) a "global threat" after the release of a collaborative study.
  • Arctic Sea Ice
    Arctic sea ice extent and volume is the lowest ever...
  • Record Temps in Greenland
    In July, melting occurred on over 97% of the surface of Greenland's ice sheets.
  • Tanning Sprays
    DHA (the effective ingredient in spray tans) has caused DNA changes in cells in laboratory tests.
  • Perfluorinated Compounds
    After you read this, you will never eat microwave popcorn again...and possibly anything out of a french fry box or pizza box.
  • Synthetic Clothes Unraveling
    Microplastic remnants from washing clothes are polluting our waters. A polyester garment can release more than 1,900 fibres per garment, per wash, and that ends up in fish, and then us, if we eat the fish. What goes around, comes around.
  • Wal-Mart Is HUGE
    Walmart’s the largest grocery store in the U.S., the largest retailer in the world, the leader in global corporate revenue and the largest employer in existence.
  • Atrazine
    Please sign the petitions recommending the EPA ban atrazine -- deadline is coming soon. Learn more...

More Posts: Blog Home